County health officials oppose BOE’s decision to keep masks optional in schools

County Health Director Nina Oliver outlines her concerns regarding masks being optional in schools during the County Consolidated Human Services Board meeting Monday. (Cheryl Burke screenshot)

MOREHEAD CITY — County health officials said Monday they oppose the school board’s Jan. 4 decision to keep masks optional in schools with the recent surge in COVID-19 cases due to the omicron variant.

“Vaccinations and masking are the highest protection available in schools and that’s what we continue to recommend in our school system,” Health Director Nina Oliver said during the County Consolidated Human Services Board meeting, held via Zoom. “The benefit is to keep kids in school and the best way we can do that is using masks.”

She pointed out that board members, in the fall, had originally agreed if the county positivity rate went above 5% they would require masks inside school buildings. However, in November, the school board voted to remove that benchmark and instead review additional data before requiring masks.

As of Monday, the county’s positivity rate was 17.5%. The positivity rate reflects the percentage of those being tested who are positive for COVID-19.

Consolidated Human Services Director Cindy Holman echoed Ms. Oliver’s concerns.

“We are experiencing a significant spike in cases. We ask you (Consolidated Human Services board members) to support us when we continue to recommend and try to follow unpopular guidance coming from the CDC and the state,” she said. “We genuinely desire for our community to be healthy and we are going to keep on keeping on even when it’s unpopular.”

Consolidated Human Services Board Chairman Carol Wray endorsed health officials’ recommendations.

“As a board, we will continue to support you,” Ms. Wray said.

Board member Dr. Gregory Reichert, a physician, agreed with Ms. Oliver’s recommendation and thanked her for continuing to provide information based on the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and science to the public.

“It gets hard saying the truth over and over again and it gets hard when the information is not heeded,” he said. “I personally know it’s exhausting, but keep it up.”

In response to county health officials’ concerns, County Board of Education Chairman Clark Jenkins said Monday night following the meeting, “We monitor all facets of our community and school data daily and if we need to make a change in policy we will do so.”

Superintendent Dr. Rob Jackson, in an email response Tuesday, said, “The Board of Education continues to monitor COVID metrics. Face-coverings are currently optional and may be worn throughout the school system. The school system has and will continue to follow all requirements of the Carteret County Health Department, and we appreciate their great work throughout the pandemic.”

As of Friday, there were 39 new confirmed cases of COVID-19 reported in county schools from Jan. 3-6. Teachers reported back to classrooms Jan. 3 after the Christmas holidays, with students reporting back Jan. 5. Of the cases, 17 were students and 22 were employees.

Ms. Holman further said Monday that the health department has been inundated with calls from parents asking for guidance on isolation requirements when their children are positive for COVID or are exposed to others who are positive.

“Today, we have begun to receive a greatly increased number of phone calls from parents indicating that they have been directed to us by school nurses. These parents had received no information about contact tracing or quarantining,” she said. “We will accept these calls and give instruction around both contact tracing and quarantining to the very best of our ability. We want you to know that this will increase the burden on the health department, which is already inundated with testing and vaccinating.”

In response, Dr. Jackson said school nurses and personnel “are working hard to assist parents in understanding quarantining requirements as they continue to be changed by the state. The state toolkit has been revised multiple times this year and twice within the last week. Rapid changes can be confusing, and we are here to help students, staff and families understand the process. We truly appreciate the patience, flexibility, and support of parents and community members as we navigate this pandemic together.”

Ms. Oliver listed other concerns she had with practices currently being used in schools, including a 3-foot minimum distance instead of 6 feet for contact tracing when someone is exposed to COVID-19. She also was worried about the school system using antibody tests as a method to determine if someone is protected.

“The CDC is stating that antibody tests will no longer be used to make that determination,” she said. “That is not our decision, but the state’s and CDC.”

As of Jan. 10, the StrongSchoolsNC Toolkit states that the American Association of Pediatrics recommends universal masking in schools, which is what the CDC also recommends.

 

Contact Cheryl Burke at 252-726-7081, ext. 255; email Cheryl@thenewstimes.com; or follow on Twitter @cherylccnt.

(11) comments

drewski

So county health dept and a Dr on health board suggest masks, boe replies with placating nonsense, is anyone surprised?

Parents unaware from school about contact tracing or quarantine procedures.

Dr. Jackson ust got a thou a month raise, cause .. he panders to the majority who think masks and shots are for " darn libs"

When it's your child who is sick, and your mom who is dead it might put things in a different perspective?

noitall

“Vaccinations and masking are the highest protection available in schools and that’s what we continue to recommend in our school system,” PROVE IT.

drewski

Small pox, German measles, polio.. the plethora of childhood shots, I am simply dumbfounded that suddenly " proof" is required for 35% of the US population.

New library opening in mhc, likely proof is available there?

Dak

Like you would bother reading any research papers we pulled together showing relevant data, or learn anything from it.

CKM

Amen!

drewski

Meanwhile. Brunswick Co. Knoecks off school 2 days early and makes masks mandatory when the kids return next Tuesday. Cited reason staff shortage and high covid numbers.

One has to wonder just what on earth our school board is thinking?

Perhaps it is time to close the health dept? Since obviously they have become " woke".

*** shakes head slowly and sadly***

dc

More employees than students positive. Concern for elderly with health issues. Seems distancing probably more important than masks but tough to accommodate. Everyone will eventually get Omicron.

David Collins

Easy there cowboy , the jabs and masking is all they can do besides remote learning and we have found out what a farce that can be . Just gonna have to ride this one out . Unless ……….

CKM

It was said when last mask mandate became optional if the county’s rates exceeds 5% of Covid cases the mask mandate would be reinstated. On January 4th the last Board meeting every member voted to keep masks optional with the county Covid rate at 11%.

Interestingly enough one member did inquire about the Governors issued KN95 masks for teachers. I attended and spoke at that meeting asking for a mask mandate. The issue was definitely not up for consideration.

Exactly ten days later the children are back to virtual “ learning “. These kids are caught up in a political storm and teachers are getting sick. At this moment we are virtual learning and mask optional does that make any sense ?

We are all responsible for this. We have to stand up and help to fix this in anyway we can #carteretcountystrong

JoeM

Turn off MSM and break free of the fear driven mass psychosis. Study the data coming out of the strictest US states and other countries, they are failing miserably and STILL continue down their path (e.g. https://mhalink.informz.net/mhalink/data/images/220114WWUcrisis.pdf). Early treatment protocols give results, search it. The mRNA gene-therapy 'vaccine$' have massive problems. Sars-Cov-2 is here to stay, just like the flu and cold. Our healthcare systems are captured by Big Pharma and many governmental leaders are godless fools.

Bottom_Fish

Well, thanks for the advice, Doctor JoeM! You are a doctor, right? You seem to know an awful lot about virology and epidemiology...(lol)

Welcome to the discussion.

As a privately owned web site, we reserve the right to edit or remove comments that contain spam, advertising, vulgarity, threats of violence, racism, anti-Semitism, or personal/abusive/condescending attacks on other users or goading them. The same applies to trolling, the use of multiple aliases, or just generally being a jerk. Enforcement of this policy is at the sole discretion of the site administrators and repeat offenders may be blocked or permanently banned without warning.