The Trump Administration continues to pursue a trade war with China, a war that it is losing. The usual results appear: trade relationships are exacerbated, production suffers and labor resources are allocated inefficiently. Instead of trading productively, relative productive disadvantages are created.

Trump continues to do this in the face of evidence that these policies are producing problems for the American economy. For example, business taxed investment and Gross Domestic Product have been adversely affected by the continual use of tariffs to accomplish these goals. One of the effects of these policies has been to weaken the yuan, the Chinese currency. As it weakens, which means it takes reduced amounts of foreign currency to buy it, Chinese policies have produced increasing tariffs of U.S. goods and reduced the tariffs on goods imported from other countries, thereby making it more difficult for U.S. goods to enter China.

This is not a new result, as protectionist measures, such as tariffs, are being employed to burden and alter free trade policies between countries. No better example of these burdens can be found than in the California wine business, which has seen dramatic increases in surcharges on wine, reports Margot Roosevelt in a recent article in the Los Angeles Times. Those taxes have resulted in a dramatic 93 percent surcharge on each bottle of California wine, making it much harder to sell abroad. Meanwhile, Australia and Chile export their wines to China taxed at a much lower rate as a direct result of their separate free trade agreements.

Using protectionist devices to alter trade so as to make trade with other nations result in benefits for trading nations has been used for centuries. Protectionism has been shown to modify gain from free trade by many economists. The most well known, David Ricardo, put forth the idea of nations producing where they have a comparative advantage, in 1817. Nations producing where they have a comparative advantage and then trading for goods where they lack cost advantages is the foundation of mutual gains for nations Ricardo showed and economists today agree.

As tariffs and other restrictions on free trade are used, the possibility of gains from free trade is modified. Any improvement will not take place in an atmosphere of hostility and suspicion. Ample evidence for that conclusion appears in the relationship that now exists between China and the United States.

Without a doubt, increases in tariffs and other barriers used by both China and the U.S. will act to reduce the gains from trade with each other, worsen the political relationship each country has with the other and complicate the steps both China and the U.S. must take to improve political and economic relationships.

David Kaplan of Santa Barbara, Calif., is a retired economics professor.

(3) comments

David Collins

From Santa Barbara Calif. is he ? Figures. He needs to stay retired and pray to his plants for forgiveness.


Do tell: What have David Kaplan written here that is wrong?

David Collins

Guess you meant, what has David Kaplan written here that is wrong? Actually nothing due to it being his opinion. That’s all, just his opinion. Tariffs are meant to level the playing field and raise revenue but can also be used punitively. Really, what does China offer other than cheap stuff that is mostly junk. Short service life and low quality. They also offered pet food and pet toys that turned out to be poisonous to Fluffy and Fido. Nice guys , they are and their opioid pills , complete with mysterious ingredients are becoming legendary but they are cheap and copious. Why would they treat we folks any differently than our beloved pets? Yup, China fills all our needs and at a bargain price. Don’t they?

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.